End of sterilization as a condition for official sex change

We wholeheartedly welcome the Constitutional Court’s decision to abolish the legal requirements for surgery and sterilization as a condition for official sex change. This decision is an important victory for personal autonomy and human dignity for transgender and non-binary people in our country.

In its ruling, the Constitutional Court today clearly stated that the legal requirements of genital reassignment surgery and disabling reproductive function are in direct conflict with trans people’s fundamental right to the protection of their bodily integrity and personal autonomy, and thus violate their human dignity. Transgender identity is not a disease and gender reassignment should not be conditional on interference with bodily integrity, which is irreversible and can have serious health consequences.

In its decision, the Court stressed that while the State may have a legitimate interest in defining the conditions for gender reassignment so that an individual’s status is clear and authentic, this interest must not override the fundamental rights of the persons concerned. To require automatically the performance of an invasive and irreversible surgical procedure merely for the sake of legal certainty is manifestly disproportionate and contrary to human dignity.

We welcome the fact that the Constitutional Court in this case did not merely reflect earlier case law, but conducted a comprehensive constitutional analysis in which it prioritized the individual rights and needs of trans and non-binary persons over a formalistic interpretation of the law. It is also positive that the Constitutional Court does not directly interfere in legislative drafting on this sensitive issue, but leaves sufficient room for the legislators to adopt new legislation reflecting this decision. At the same time, it temporarily leaves the existing conditions in force in order to avoid legal uncertainty.

This decision of the Constitutional Court is an important step towards greater inclusiveness and respect for the rights of transgender people in the Czech Republic. As a skeptic and a secular humanist, I welcome the fact that Czech law in this area is abandoning outdated and medically outmoded concepts and is moving closer to the standards of modern democratic countries that prioritize the rights and dignity of the individual over ideological or religious dogmas.

It is now up to the legislators, in the spirit of this decision, to enact legislation that fully reflects the current understanding of transgender identity and ensures that trans people have the right to self-determination in gender reassignment without being forced to undergo irreversible interference with their bodily integrity.
We expect the new legislation to be drafted in accordance with the principles of human rights, dignity and scientific knowledge.

.

_{sources:
https://www.usoud.cz/aktualne/chirurgicky-zakrok-vcetne-sterilizace-jako-podminka-uredni-zmeny-pohlavi-neobstal-pred-ustavnim-soudem
https://www.seznamzpravy.cz/clanek/domaci-zivot-v-cesku-ustavni-soud-operace-nebude-podminkou-uredni-zmeny-pohlavi-251323
https://denikn.cz/minuta/1419422
https://zpravy.aktualne.cz/domaci/ustavni-soud-rozhodl-ze-operace-uz-nebude-podminkou-uredni-z/r~6bce93420c4311ef80bfac1f6b220ee8/}